Donovan mcnabb4/2/2023 ![]() ![]() That’s pointless due to what’s mentioned in this article: the game changes over time. Whenever these debates come up about comparing current era players to others in a previous era, the biggest mistake is to compare their counting numbers. Which is why Aikman got in on the first ballot, and McNabb has never been close. So McNabb, while a good player, simply does not have the kind of Hall of Fame candidacy that Aikman had. Right or wrong, Super Bowl rings play an inordinate part in a quarterback’s Hall of Fame candidacy. Aikman won three Super Bowl rings while McNabb won zero. Although their careers overlapped by two years, for all intents and purposes, Aikman and McNabb played in different eras.Īnd, of course, the numbers that really matter to Aikman’s and McNabb’s Hall of Fame candidacies are three and zero. In other words, the significant increase in passing efficiency in the NFL had barely begun over the course of Aikman’s career, but it exploded during McNabb’s career. By McNabb’s rookie year, 1999, the average passer rating had climbed only slightly, to 77.1, but by McNabb’s final year, 2011, the league average passer rating had risen all the way to 84.3. But that’s a bit misleading.įor starters, McNabb played in a better passing era than Aikman: In Aikman’s rookie year, 1989, the league average passer rating was 75.6. ![]() McNabb does, in fact, have better numbers than Aikman: McNabb threw for more yards and more touchdowns, with fewer interceptions. “My numbers are better than Troy Aikman.” My numbers speak for themselves,” McNabb told TMZ. My numbers are better than Troy Aikman, but he has Super Bowl rings.Former Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb has never even been a finalist for the Pro Football Hall of Fame, but he believes he should already have a bust in Canton. McNabb invoked Aikman’s name when he told TMZ Sports last year he believes he should be in the Hall of Fame. The only quarterbacks with a score lower than 70 who are in the Hall of Fame are Kelly and Dallas Cowboys legend Troy Aikman. The Hall of Fame Monitor’s average quarterback score is 103. McNabb is right above Carson Palmer (56.02), who retired after the 2017 season with a similar resume. The good news is McNabb’s 56.23 score isn’t far behind Jim Kelly‘s 59.10, and Kelly was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2002. Pro-Football Reference’s Hall of Fame Monitor, which uses everything from traditional stats to Pro Bowl and All-Pro selections, places McNabb in 44th place. McNabb also ran for 3,459 yards and 29 touchdowns on 5.6 yards per carry. McNabb ended his career with a 98-62-1 record and completed 59% of his passes for 37,276 yards, 234 touchdowns, and 117 interceptions. | Hunter Martin/NFLPhotoLibrary/Getty Imagesĭonovan McNabb has an impressive Hall of Fame case for a quarterback who only had one losing record in a season where he started at least 10 games. Will McNabb eventually be inducted into the Hall of Fame? Donovan McNabb has the most wins by a quarterback in Philadelphia Eagles franchise history. It also likely played a role in McNabb’s Hall of Fame case. Although McNabb inked a long-term extension with the Redskins, he only lasted one year in Washington and played his final season with the Minnesota Vikings in 2011.Ī forgettable finish to McNabb’s career hurt his legacy, especially as other quarterbacks were playing deep into their 30s. The six-time Pro Bowler threw 24 touchdowns to 17 interceptions in 16 playoff outings.Ī popular quarterback who appeared on the cover of Madden NFL 06, McNabb’s Eagles tenure ended with an April 2010 trade to the Washington Redskins. ![]() McNabb won at least one playoff game in six of his seven postseason appearances. McNabb evolved from a traditional dual-threat quarterback into one of the league’s top pocket passers who could also make plays with his legs.ĭonovan McNabb led the Eagles to five NFC championship game appearances and a Super Bowl appearance after the 2004 season. But as of now, McNabb is statistically and historically the best quarterback in franchise history. At the rate Carson Wentz is going when he’s healthy, Donovan McNabb may not hold this title much longer. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |